News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)
News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)






Help RAWA: Order from our wish list on

RAWA Channel on Youtube

Follow RAWA on Twitter

Join RAWA on Facebook

McClatchy, November 19, 2009

Clinton, warlord Dostum are honored guests at Karzai fete

"You can't bring democracy with butchers," said Wadir Safi, a political science professor at Kabul University. "You cannot bring democracy with war criminals."


President Hamid Karzai began his second term Thursday under international pressure to select a Cabinet that can regain the trust of disillusioned Afghans, quash widespread government corruption and build a reliable military that can take charge of his country's defense.

However, the competition between foreign demands and domestic political IOUs was on display in the palace hall, where 800 invited guests attended Karzai's inauguration ceremony.

The journalist Ahmed Rashid noticed pieces of flesh on the ground during a visit to General Dostum's headquarters near Mazar-i-Sharif. Rashid asked a guard whether a goat had just been slaughtered for a meal, and was told that the remains were, in fact, those of a soldier who had been caught stealing. General Dostum had ordered him to be tied to the tracks of a tank which then drove around the courtyard shredding the body.
The Independent, March 11, 2008

On one side of the cavernous room sat Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, who's warned that the international community is losing patience with Karzai.

On the other side was Abdul Rashid Dostum, the Afghan warlord who's become a symbol of cronyism and government corruption. Dostum was stripped of his top military post after he was accused of war crimes and investigated for enacting vigilante justice on the streets of Kabul.

Although foreign leaders have demanded that Karzai sideline Dostum and other discredited political allies, the Afghan president is also under pressure to reward those, such as Dostum, who helped him win re-election.

Several leading political reformers are refusing to work with Karzai, and the president may have to rely on questionable allies who alienate Afghan citizens and the foreign governments that have spent billions and lost hundreds of troops defending Afghanistan from Taliban extremists."You can't bring democracy with butchers," said Wadir Safi, a political science professor at Kabul University. "You cannot bring democracy with war criminals."

Before returning to Washington, Clinton sidestepped a direct question about the role of Afghan warlords in Karzai's new government by saying that the Obama administration expects to see "an effective government that respects the rights of the people.""The road ahead is fraught with challenges and imperfect choices," Clinton said at the U.S. Embassy. "Setbacks are inevitable, and we have to be realistic about what we can accomplish, but we are also clear-eyed about the stakes."

The push for political reform comes at a decisive time in the Obama administration's fierce debate over whether the U.S. should send more troops to Afghanistan, and if so, how many.

Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal, America's top military commander in Afghanistan, has warned that the U.S. could lose the war within a year unless Obama sends a massive new counterinsurgency force to protect civilians and train Afghan forces to take over.

U.S. Ambassador Karl Eikenberry, himself a retired general, has warned Obama that the military campaign could be undercut unless Karzai cleans up his government.

In his address, Karzai said he'd like to see trained Afghan forces in charge of security within five years.

"I want Afghanistan to become a country that is capable of defending itself, and where peace reigns across the whole nation," Karzai told an audience that included Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari and British Foreign Minister David Miliband.

Karzai's resistance to outside pressure has soured his relations with international allies."There's limited patience now," said one Western diplomat in Kabul, who spoke only on the condition of anonymity in order to talk candidly about Karzai. "This is really the 'Last Chance Saloon' for Karzai, and we'll see in the coming weeks or months if he is serious about the pledges he has made."

Relations have been especially strained by the fraud-tainted vote in August that led to Karzai's re-election.

Karzai eventually acceded to U.S. pressure to accept a runoff because of widespread voter fraud in the first round. However, the second-place finisher, former Foreign Minister Abdullah Abdullah, decided to drop out of the runoff after the Afghan president refused to overhaul the voting process.

Dostum the warlord
The Independent, March 11, 2008: "General Abdul Rashid Dostum, a man of immense power and huge wealth whose name became synonymous with bloodshed and betrayal during the long years of conflict."

In his half-hour address Thursday, Karzai delivered a few polite jabs at his critics.

He suggested that news reports have exaggerated the corruption in Afghanistan, and he vowed to press American leaders to do more to reduce NATO bombings that kill civilians.

The swearing-in ceremony took place amid extraordinary security measures across Kabul to prevent Taliban or al-Qaida forces from attacking.Kabul's traffic-clogged streets were nearly deserted as security forces cordoned off large swaths of the city around the presidential palace. Afghanistan declared Thursday a national holiday and urged residents to stay at home.

While the heavy security prevented any attacks in Kabul, insurgents staged two attacks in other parts of Afghanistan that killed 12 people.

Authorities said a suicide bomber attacked a convoy of Afghan security forces, killing 10 in southern Uruzgan province. A second suicide bomber hit American forces in the adjacent Zabul province, killing two U.S. soldiers.

The attacks contributed to the somber reception Karzai received from Afghan voters.Yar Mohammed watched Karzai's speech on a television in the small, two-aisle grocery store that he's owned for decades. He voted for Karzai five years ago in Afghanistan's first democratic election, but he refused to support the president this time.

"Karzai is not reliable. He's worthless," said Mohammed, who blamed the president for failing to bring any measure of stability to Afghanistan in his first term. "It's useless to test someone who has already tested."

(Shukoor is a McClatchy Newspapers special correspondent.)

Category: Warlords, US-NATO, HR Violations, Corruption - Views: 14863


Most Viewed