News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)
News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)




Add RAWA RSS Feed to Feedreaders



Help RAWA: Order from our wish list on

RAWA Channel on Youtube

Follow RAWA on Twitter

Join RAWA on Facebook

The Independent, June 14, 2011

A decade on, Afghanistan lacks police force worthy of name

The US has spent more than 25 billion USD (15.4bn Pounds) to train and equip Afghan forces since 2001

By Jonathan Owen

Not a single Afghan police or army unit is capable of maintaining law and order in the war-torn country without the support of coalition forces, the Independent reveals.

Almost a decade after international troops were sent in to overthrow the Taliban and help to establish a functioning democracy in Afghanistan, a combination of poor training, lack of numbers, corruption and illiteracy has left the country unable to protect its people.

Brian Martin, Ex-Marine and US mentor of Afghan National Police (ANP), instructs a student during the fire arms component of tactical training program
Brian Martin, Ex-Marine and US mentor of Afghan National Police (ANP), instructs a student during the fire arms component of tactical training program (TTC) during the 2nd week of an 8-week course at the Regional Training Centre (RTC) in Herat, Afghanistan, on Sunday, August 3, 2008. The US has spent more than US$25 billion (£15.4bn) to train and equip Afghan forces since 2001 but has not got any positive results. (Photo: Adam Ferguson / TIME)

The grim official assessment of the capabilities of the Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF) is a major blow to the hopes of a troop withdrawal by 2014, a timescale that assumes the ANSF will be able to start taking the lead in fighting the Taleban from next month.

And the commander of Nato's mission to train the ANSF has admitted the task will not be complete until at least 2016.

This comes after a decade in which tens of billions of dollars have been spent building Afghan forces. Yet they remain too dependent on coalition forces, according to a report on Afghanistan from the US Department of Defence.

It cites assessments made in February that show how out of more than 400 army and police units in Afghanistan, none are rated as independent - defined as capable "without assistance from coalition forces".

The International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) will release another assessment this week, but experts are not expecting major change. There are signs of progress, with army units deemed effective "with advisers" up 45 per cent (from 42 to 61) and those effective "with assistance" rising by 73 per cent (from 49 to 85) between last September and February.

But more than half the police and army units need coalition soldiers to fight alongside them. Only a third are effective with just military advisers in support.

The report, looking at the period between last October and this March, warns: "ANA units are still too dependent on coalition forces for operations, and specifically logistical support."

A "significant shortfall" of 740 trainers and mentors "poses a strategic risk to ANSF growth and an increased risk to transition".

Citing the "slow development of governance", it warns that "despite the gains in security and in ANSF growth and development, the Afghan Government faces significant political challenges which could potentially threaten the progress made in the last six months" while "extensive bureaucracy and areas of corruption continue to present serious challenges".

The US has spent more than US$25 billion (£15.4bn) to train and equip Afghan forces since 2001. Literacy remains a problem. Although more than 63,000 ANSF have completed literacy training since November 2009, none is above the reading age of a 9-year-old.

Speaking in Washington last week, Lieutenant-General William B. Caldwell, commander of Nato's training mission in Afghanistan, hinted that politically driven timescales do not match reality.

"As far as the training mission goes, we won't complete doing what we need to do till about 2016, 2017."

Category: US-NATO, Corruption - Views: 9222


10.06.2011: Afghanistan to be handed over to gangsters
08.06.2011: Afghanistan tackles sexual abuse of children within the police
21.05.2011: Afghan police were “rotten to the core”
10.05.2011: Afghan police committing crimes with impunity: Oxfam
07.02.2011: Afghan police “have drug culture”
03.02.2011: Afghan police “nearly as unpopular as Taliban in south”
16.12.2010: Illiteracy Breeds Corruption, Slows Training Among Afghan Recruits
29.11.2010: Good Cop, Bad Cop: Afghanistan’s National Police
19.11.2010: AFGHANISTAN: NGOs call on NATO, Afghan government to stop using local militias
11.10.2010: AFP faces hard job to train corrupt candidates
26.09.2010: Afghan “vote-rigging videos” emerge
26.09.2010: Violence kills 100 Afghan police every month: govt
27.07.2010: Wikileaks Afghanistan: police chief doubled as Iranian spy
03.06.2010: Afghanistan police corruption is fuelling insurgency
10.05.2010: Corruption, incompetence charges plague new Afghan police force
10.05.2010: AFGHANISTAN: Running on drugs, corruption and aid
30.03.2010: UN report: Afghans plagued by poverty, corruption
20.03.2010: The Gang That Couldn’t Shoot Straight
11.03.2010: Afghan police recruits abusing drugs, US report finds
06.02.2010: Afghan police kill seven boys collecting firewood
21.01.2010: Kabul traffic cops fight to keep city moving but government slow to pay
06.11.2009: Afghan police: Corrupt and brutal, and still not fit for purpose
29.07.2009: Child Rapist Police Return Behind U.S., UK Troops
18.02.2009: ‘Two-thirds of Afghan police take illegal drugs’
28.10.2008: The Police Take Bribe, Even from the Beggars of the Shrine of Mazar-e-Sharif
16.08.2008: Rapists 'bribed police to escape jail term'
15.06.2008: Over a dozen wounded as police fire on anti-NATO protestors
10.06.2008: Afghanistan's Future Threatened by Poor Police, Balkenende Says
10.05.2008: Two protesters were killed, six wounded in Afghan police shooting
12.06.2007: US-led forces kill seven Afghan police during a "friendly fighting"
05.03.2007: Afghanistan's police 'part of the problem'
03.03.2007: Protesters complain ill-treatment by police in Helmand
01.02.2007: ''Replace corrupt governors, police chiefs''
10.01.2007: "In some areas of Helmand, the police are your worst enemy"
04.05.2006: Reject Known Abusers as Police Chiefs
06.06.2006: Afghan police part of the problem
05.06.2006: Attack of Police to Girl's Dormitory in Balkh
07.11.2006: Police rapes a girl in Takhar, Women are sold in Faryab


Most Viewed