News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)




Add RAWA RSS Feed to Feedreaders



RAWA Photo Gallery
From RAWA Photo Gallery

Help RAWA: Order from our wish list on

RAWA Channel on Youtube

Follow RAWA on Twitter

Join RAWA on Facebook

IRIN, November 10, 2010

Analysis: In pursuit of justice in Afghanistan

Under a controversial amnesty law passed by the government in 2008, the government and state prosecutors cannot investigate and document pre-2001 crimes and hold alleged criminals accountable

The International Criminal Court (ICC) should start investigating war crimes and crimes against humanity committed by various warring groups in Afghanistan since 2002 to help end a culture of impunity, says Sima Samar, chairwoman of the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission (AIHRC).

Sayyaf poster with blood stains
People in Kabul show their hatred by throwing blood stains on brutal warlord Abdul Rab Rasool Sayyaf's election poster

“Without genuine justice, Afghanistan will continue suffering from rights violations, war and lawlessness,” she told IRIN.

The ICC’s remit is restricted to the investigation of crimes committed since July 2002, but thousands of Afghans, mostly civilians, have died and many more have been wounded, displaced and affected by armed violence over the past three decades.

Egregious human rights violations such as large-scale killings of civilians, forced displacement, rape and widespread destruction of private and public properties were committed by Mujahedin militias in April 1992 and March 1993 in Kabul, according to Human Rights Watch. Fighters under the control of Vice-Presidents Mohammad Qasim Fahim and Karim Khalili, and other powerful individuals such as Burhanudin Rabani (chairman of the Peace High Council) and Abdul Rab Rasoul Sayaf (member of parliament and member of the Peace High Council) were involved in the internecine fighting.

Mass rape as a weapon of war was reportedly used by militia factions such as Wahadat-e-Islami, Junbishe-e-Islami, Jamiat-e-Islami, Hezb-e-Islami and Itehad-e-Islami whose leaders are still in power in Afghanistan, according to a UN interagency report covering the period April 1978 to December 2001.

A transitional justice plan designed to address past rights violations expired in 2009 but failed to achieve most of its objectives. Human rights activists accuse President Hamid Karzai’s alleged allies of scuppering the plan to evade accountability.

However, Karzai has defended his alliance with controversial militia leaders whom he has called “respectable Jihadi leaders”. Karzai was a member of the anti-Soviet militias based in Pakistan but which fought in Afghanistan in 1979-1992. He came to power in 2001 at the head of a US-led coalition which toppled the Taliban.

Under a controversial amnesty law passed by the government in 2008, the government and state prosecutors cannot investigate and document pre-2001 crimes and hold alleged criminals accountable.

The call for ICC intervention comes one year after the Court’s chief prosecutor, Luis Moreno-Ocampo, announced that his office was collecting information about possible war crimes committed by the warring parties in Afghanistan.

Afghan rights groups hailed the move and called on the ICC to help end the culture of impunity enjoyed by militias and warring groups.

“We don’t have the capacity to investigate war crimes and the only legitimate institution to intervene is the ICC,” said the AIHRC’s Samar.

“ICC is the only point of hope left for Afghans,” said Ajmal Samadi of the Kabul-based Afghanistan Rights Monitor, adding that the government and its foreign supporters were unwilling to uncover the truth and bring major criminals to book.

The ICC chief prosecutor’s office initially agreed to answer IRIN’s questions about the situation in Afghanistan but later declined to do so.

No answers

destroyed Kabul
More than 90% of Kabul was destroyed in the civil war from 1992-1996 between different factions of fundamentalists of current Northern Alliance.

In a report to the UN General Assembly in August, the ICC said it had not received answers to questions it sent to the Afghan government in 2008.

Waheed Omar, a spokesman for Karzai, did not confirm receipt of the ICC questions by the government, and Foreign Ministry officials have refused to comment.

Over the past five years, the ICC has issued arrest warrants for several individuals including current Sudanese President Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir, Ahmad Muhmmad Harun (former interior minister) and Ali Kushayb (alleged leader of the militia/Janjaweed) for alleged crimes in Darfur 2002-2005.

Several others accused of involvement in appalling crimes in Darfur are also awaiting their verdicts.

“The situation in Sudan is similar to Afghanistan: warlords, corruption, ineffective judiciary, weakened victims and the abuse of religion to justify crimes,” said Samar, who also worked as the UN human rights rapporteur for Sudan, 2005-2009.

“Afghanistan is a state party to the ICC and therefore it must not remain silent about the situation here,” she said, adding that the UN should encourage the ICC to probe crimes in Afghanistan.

However, Elies van Sliedregt, a professor of international criminal law at the VU University of Amsterdam, said there was a lack of political will in the UN Security Council to prosecute war crimes in Afghanistan.

Three permanent members of the Security Council - USA, UK and France - and their NATO allies have been involved in the war in Afghanistan since 2002.

“The ICC prosecutor has already a lot on his plate and to my mind the international community, particularly the human rights community, are overstating the role of the ICC in ending impunity,” Sliedregt told IRIN.

Crimes continue

A war crime is a serious violation of international humanitarian law committed during international or internal armed conflict, according to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).

Willful killing and torturing of a protected person (wounded or sick combatant, prisoner of war, civilian), among other things, constitutes a war crime.

When practised widely and systematically, other serious human rights violations - mostly reported during war and social turmoil - are crimes against humanity which include murder, deportation, imprisonment, torture, sexual offences and prosecutions based on religious, ethnic and other kinds of discrimination.

“Crimes against humanity have happened over the past 30 years and continue to happen today,” Omar told IRIN, adding that the government was trying to tackle the problem.

He said the Afghan government would not oppose the ICC or other bodies working in Afghanistan “within the laws and regulations of Afghanistan”.

“We have always maintained that the war in Afghanistan is still ongoing; we do not fit the definition of a post-conflict country,” he said.

Omar’s assertions, however, are repudiated by rights activists who say the conflict remains unabated due to lack of justice and accountability.

Samar of the AIHRC and other rights activists, meanwhile, accuse Karzai of focusing on his own political survival.

“The government sacrificed justice for stability and the result has been disastrous,” said Samar, adding that Afghans had lost confidence in their leaders to give them justice.

Most of the over 4,100 Afghans interviewed by the AIHRC in 2005 about how to address past crimes said they were victims of human rights violations and wanted alleged criminals brought to justice. They said this would bring security and stability to the country.

Five years on, crimes continue to happen and the victims are still seeking justice.

Category: Warlords, HR Violations, Corruption - Views: 7315


09.11.2010: Australian Ties to Afghan Warlord Harms Stability, Rights Activists Say
02.11.2010: Australia’s helping hand to warlord condemned
12.10.2010: Afghan Warlords, a Larger Stability Threat Than Taliban
08.10.2010: Afghanistan’s Reservoir Dogs: security firms criticised over “warlord payments”
04.10.2010: Afghanistan nine years on
24.09.2010: Warlord TV
23.08.2010: Afghanistan: Land of Injustice and Warlords
23.08.2010: Afghanistan’s new war crimes museum punts on still-powerful warlords
12.08.2010: The real story behind Time’s Afghan woman cover: American complicity
14.06.2010: Danger Looms if Afghan Vice President & Warlord becomes Country’s President
14.05.2010: Victims of Afghan wars demand justice before peace
18.04.2010: “In My Father’s House They Gathered All the Women into One Room”
26.03.2010: The Bloody Hands of Gulbuddin Hekmatyar
25.03.2010: Afghan amnesty for militants draws UN condemnation
05.03.2010: ‘Afghan women lawmakers hamstrung by warlords’
27.02.2010: Afghanistan worlords’ unwelcome return
18.02.2010: Two Afghan women are publicly flogged by local warlord in Ghor
11.02.2010: Afghanistan quietly brings into force Taliban amnesty law
27.01.2010: In Afghanistan: Embracing Gulbuddin Hekmatyar Is No Method at All
17.01.2010: Dealing with brutal Afghan warlords is a mistake
17.12.2009: Warlords Re-emerging in North
14.12.2009: Canada ‘defended’ torturer
31.10.2009: NATO forces turn to warlords
10.07.2009: U.S. Said to Have Averted Inquiry Into ’01 Afghan Killings
06.06.2009: The U.S. and the Afghan Tragedy
10.05.2009: Karzai in move to share power with Hekmatyar, warlord wanted by US
04.05.2009: Karzai ignored UN pleas, named notorious warlord as vice president
27.02.2009: Western officials, Taliban engaged in secret talks
01.01.2009: A Day Afghans Will Always Remember
16.12.2008: From the CIA to the ISI to the Lashkar-e-Taiba: Mumbai Terror’s Afghan Roots
12.12.2008: As possible Afghan war-crimes evidence removed, US silent
11.07.2008: Afghan Warlords, Formerly Backed By the CIA, Now Turn Their Guns On U.S. Troops
03.06.2008: Connection of Some Afghan Authorities with Armed Groups
30.05.2008: Gulbuddin Hekmatyar’s spokesman and son-in-law freed in Kabul
16.04.2008: Afghan parliament committee drafts Taliban-style moral law
11.03.2008: Warlord under siege after 'kidnap and torture' of former ally
19.02.2008: Feared Afghan strongman suspended from government post
08.02.2008: Waiting for justice
06.02.2008: Northern Warlord Flexes His Muscles
03.02.2008: Former Warlord in Standoff With Police at Kabul Home
10.01.2008: America's great game: The 2001 invasion was planned before 9/11
23.11.2007: Ex-commanders warn of dire consequences if ignored
19.11.2007: 1.1 Million Dollar Contact of Canadian Military with a Company of Infamous Warlord
19.11.2007: Afghan boy dancers sexually abused by former warlords
08.11.2007: Warlords no better than Taliban, says Afghan MP
03.11.2007: Afghan criminals and warlords
28.10.2007: Afghan Ex-Militia Leaders Hoard Illegal Arms
26.10.2007: Yunus Qanooni: Friend or Foe of Democracy in Afghanistan?
18.10.2007: Strongman's Reign of Fear in the Northern Afghanistan
13.09.2007: For residents of the northern province of Takhar, there are worse things than the Taliban
29.04.2007: Afghan amnesty shows warlord's clout
16.03.2007: From frying pan to the fire
27.02.2007: 2,000 illegal armed groups active in northern Afghanistan
20.02.2007: The Upper House of Parliament Approve Amnesty For War Criminals
02.02.2007: UN opposes Afghanistan bill giving immunity to war criminals
01.02.2007: Afghan assembly grants immunity for war crimes
08.01.2007: Dostum accused for insecurity in Jawzjan, Faryab
05.05.2006: US not interested in peace in Afghanistan: Kathy Gannon


Most Viewed